Mike Kaytar played mixed and men's doubles badminton with partner Rob Parnell for Cambrian College. With Parnell, the tandem scored three OCAA Men's Doubles gold medals (1995, 1998, 1999) and Kaytar also won OCAA gold for Mixed Doubles in 1996.

Parnell and Kaytar were also successful in Men's Doubles CCAA Championships, winning gold medals in 1998 and 1999. In addition, Kaytar also scored CCAA silver in 1996 in mixed badminton.