Misty Findlay played on the St. Clair Saints women's soccer team for three seasons spanning from the 1997 to 2000 season. During her tenure she was the leading scorer in each one. Misty is the OCAA's sixth all-time leading scorer with 27 career goals and was an OCAA League All-Star in the 1999 season. Findlay also found playoff success, earning an OCAA bronze medal in 2000.

Misty was named a member of the OCAA Women's Soccer All-Millenium Team.